Gaps in USDA bird flu plan could slow response – GAO
By Christopher Doering

The Star, 26 June 2007

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The U.S. Agriculture Department is not fully prepared to cope with an outbreak of the highly pathogenic bird flu virus, a government report said on Monday. 

"While USDA has made important strides, incomplete planning at the federal and state levels, as well as several unresolved issues, could slow response and delay recovery from an outbreak," the Government Accountability Office said in its 60-page report. 

Doses of a flu vaccine is seen lying on a table in San Luis Obispo, California in this October 31, 2006 file photo. (REUTERS/Phil Klein/Files)

Worldwide, the highly pathogenic H5N1 avian influenza virus has killed 191 people since 2003, according to the U.N.'s World Health Organization. The strain has not been found in the United States. 

In an effort to prepare for H5N1, USDA rolled out a series of measures including surveillance programs, response plans to the virus and new rules that aim to prevent infected birds and products from being imported. 

Still, GAO investigators said there is uncertainty between USDA and the Department of Homeland Security as to what role each would take during an emergency. The lack of coordination between the two departments would slow initial responses as they work to figure out their jobs. 

The report also found that 14 of the 19 state response plans for bird flu reviewed by GAO were incomplete. For example, state plans often failed to include important time frames needed to assess whether they were controlling the virus. 

USDA said it accepted the recommendation "to develop additional clarity and definition" between the department and Homeland Security. 

The agency also vowed to more closely monitor high-pathogenic bird flu response plans to ensure they are appropriate should an outbreak occur. It noted a new rule that required states to develop low-pathogenic plans that must then be reviewed and approved by USDA. Some of the more mild strains can develop into the highly pathogenic virus. 

GAO said the incomplete state plans were particularly troublesome since states typically are the first to respond to a suspected outbreak. 

Government investigators also are worried about incomplete information on the number and location of birds in backyards, the ability of laboratories to handle a surge in testing, disposal of carcasses, and uncertainty as to the amount of antiviral medication needed for workers depopulating diseased animals and cleaning infected facilities. 

The investigation was requested by a bipartisan group of senators including Tom Harkin of Iowa, a Democrat, and Saxby Chambliss, a Georgia Republican. 

"This is not a new threat to this country and, while GAO highlights measures USDA has taken to prepare the country for such a threat, there should be no excuse for failing to have a stronger response system in place," said Harkin, chairman of the Senate Agriculture Committee.